Xocrates TWG: GAME OVER: Humans Win
zjore voted for Mas Tnega, who was then eaten. His next vote was for Mr. Bunsey, but that was never really a threat.
So, why did he get eaten? I figure it was maybe because Bunsey is a wolf, but it could just as easily be that that is what they want us to think so we vote for a human. It might be that he was felt to be a threat in some other way. Or he was a random human who just got picked.
I suppose the wolves might be using IE and just got annoyed at seeing his huge avatar, but that seems like a logical stretch.
So, why did he get eaten? I figure it was maybe because Bunsey is a wolf, but it could just as easily be that that is what they want us to think so we vote for a human. It might be that he was felt to be a threat in some other way. Or he was a random human who just got picked.
I suppose the wolves might be using IE and just got annoyed at seeing his huge avatar, but that seems like a logical stretch.
ynbniar wrote:So a summary then from a known human...
Foxsake - seems human to me, might be wolf, did what I asked
Phelanpt - most suspicious person to vote for me yesterday
Zjoere - also suspicious but also human
Cooper42 - voted for known human, who knows?
Ah... there's one small problem with the summary. Anyone eaten could, in fact, be wolfy... given that the game started with two separate factions of wolves, and they may not have hooked up with each other so soon. So really, we have no idea what zjoere was. Except not the vigilante.

Last edited by Shwart!! on Sat Feb 04, 2012 4:54 am, edited 3 times in total.
-
- level5
- Posts: 1186
- Joined: Fri Aug 31, 2007 4:37 pm
- Contact:
Yeah, I really don't know what was up with Jordy's decision, maybe he hoped other people would change their votes before it came to lynching time? *shrugs*
Personally, I'm starting to think that Foxsake is too. . . innocent-seeming to be a wolf, though that could be a good disguise, I can't say for sure. It sure would be nice for us to have some more ideas about who is human/isn't, does the coroner only get to check out the body of the last person lynched/shot or can he choose? Presuming he's still alive of course.
Personally, I'm starting to think that Foxsake is too. . . innocent-seeming to be a wolf, though that could be a good disguise, I can't say for sure. It sure would be nice for us to have some more ideas about who is human/isn't, does the coroner only get to check out the body of the last person lynched/shot or can he choose? Presuming he's still alive of course.
zach wrote:I still find Jordy's suicidal behaviour (which ended up saving Xarlaxas) pretty odd ... we all know what Jordy can be like sometimes, though.
With little else to go on, this, lynch Xarlaxas (Retracted)
Last edited by ynbniar on Sun Feb 05, 2012 10:52 am, edited 1 time in total.
I can't really imagine any tactical advantage for what happened if you think Jordy and I were wolves, if we were both wolves it wouldn't really matter who died if we were tied, unless we get into arguments as to which of us would be the "better" wolf.
Jordy and I had a disagreement on whether his plan would be effective or not that got rather heated and somehow ended up with bandwagons against the both of us, in the end he conceded I was right and decided he didn't want to vote for me anymore, I guess he was hoping that more people would vote for Foxsake than him, or he counted wrong, and ended up dying. . . .
Personally, I'm not really seeing anything *so* suspicious that I'd definitely want to vote for someone, but I'm going to fall back on voting for Foxsake[Redacted] as he's far too quiet and innocent-seeming, but I'm really still stuck on Day 1 voting logic.
Scratch that, shinygerbil[Redacted] is doing a really good job of keeping quiet and appearing only when people vote for him to mount a defense, so I think that he might be a bit too wolfy for his own good. . . .
Jordy and I had a disagreement on whether his plan would be effective or not that got rather heated and somehow ended up with bandwagons against the both of us, in the end he conceded I was right and decided he didn't want to vote for me anymore, I guess he was hoping that more people would vote for Foxsake than him, or he counted wrong, and ended up dying. . . .
Personally, I'm not really seeing anything *so* suspicious that I'd definitely want to vote for someone, but I'm going to fall back on voting for Foxsake[Redacted] as he's far too quiet and innocent-seeming, but I'm really still stuck on Day 1 voting logic.
Scratch that, shinygerbil[Redacted] is doing a really good job of keeping quiet and appearing only when people vote for him to mount a defense, so I think that he might be a bit too wolfy for his own good. . . .
Last edited by Xarlaxas on Sun Feb 05, 2012 12:18 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Xarlaxas wrote:I can't really imagine any tactical advantage for what happened if you think Jordy and I were wolves, if we were both wolves it wouldn't really matter who died if we were tied, unless we get into arguments as to which of us would be the "better" wolf.
Hmm, well ... maybe if Jordy was the rogue wolf, that would mean Jordy's best shot at winning the game (ie. wolf win) could be to sacrifice himself to save a "real" wolf (as those are only ones that count towards wolf victory).
I don't know. Personally I don't think you're acting suspicious yourself, maybe apart from the day 1 logic of your voting; but it's more or less the only thing any of us can do at this point. It's mostly just the suicide I'm confused about.
ynbniar wrote:With little else to go on, this, lynch Xarlaxas
While not exactly a bandwagon, Xarlaxas has the most votes (2, if I'm not mistaken) at the moment. If The Coroner is still alive (and up for it), we could always have them perform an autopsy on Jordy.
If the autopsy comes out with Jordy being human, Xarlaxas is pretty much cleared of suspicion, I think? (for now, of course

If it comes out with Jordy being a (rogue) wolf, well ... we should probably proceed with the seemingly current voting trend of the day.
Either way, in my opinion a Jordy autopsy now is probably our best bet for getting at least some valid information on the current state of the game.
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 3 guests