Postby jelco » Sun Sep 03, 2006 6:16 pm
I think xyzyxx' icon looks very good, as it's located on my desktop as for this moment of time. I must say, there are a few others up there I really like, but the big buttons etc will be scaled down so much that they have to be rendered all over again (with some AA) to make it nice again. All the detail will disappear and the missing pixels will make the thing ugly.
But I'll review all of 'em for fun.
Babylon5
...
Never mind
Chittix
They're cool, but look at my comment above on detail. If that can be solved, I think the left one on the second row would be best.
jUngle
Nice, but they're a little...home-made. Not that I can design very nice icons, but I don't think they'll look good with an official release.
Leonaken
First row...skip those.
The blue buttons are nice, and the 64x64 re-rendered with some AA-techniques would look perfect. If the button would be red, and the hazard-logo white. Because blue is more for anthrax-weapons.
martin
Cool. The large nuclear explosion would be good if you can scale it properly. But of course, the game itself is a little monotone. Something so detailed and coloured is a different style. The silo and sub are also very good. I'd prefer the silo.
Montyphy
Buttons: nice. I like the red one with white logo, without 3D-effects. Globes are too detailed to scale properly, but they're very nice.
RnSK
Now THAT one's nice. Perfect! I like it!
The_B
Look at the comment on Babylon5
TheSquire
3rd one's very good. Love 'em.
TheToyMaker
See The_B's comment.
xyzyxx
Difficult nickname, btw. Perfect one. No criticism whatsoever.
trickfred
Look a little like Montyphy's. See his comment.
Enough comments guys? Good. I'm gonna take a break now...
Jelco
"The ships hung in the sky much the same way that bricks don't."
- Douglas Adams
